central · Idaho guide

Alice Lake, Idaho: Hiking from Pettit Lake

A demanding Sawtooth lake hike with creek crossings, granite scenery, and important wilderness rules. Start at Pettit Lake and separate the parking fee from the free permit.

Alice Lake beneath the rocky peaks of Idaho’s Sawtooth Wilderness
Photo · Fredlyfish4 · CC BY-SA 3.0 · Source

Alice Lake, Idaho, is a Sawtooth Wilderness destination reached on foot from Pettit Lake. The appeal is straightforward: a mountain lake framed by granite peaks, with a substantial hike between the parking lot and the shore. The planning is less simple. Creek crossings, lingering snow, limited trailhead capacity, and wilderness rules all matter more than getting a perfect lake photograph.

Alice Lake trail facts and route choice

The Forest Service visitor guide lists Alice Lake at 6 miles one way with 1,600 feet of elevation gain, making the straightforward out-and-back approximately 12 miles. Turnaround points along the lakeshore and different route measurements can change recorded mileage. Treat this as a full hiking day, not a short lakeside stroll.

The approach begins at Pettit Lake, at the trailhead historically called Tin Cup. A 2025 Forest Service notice calls it Pettit Lake Trailhead, formerly Tin Cup Trailhead. Both names therefore appear in planning material. Confirm that your navigation is taking you to the Pettit Lake access, not another Sawtooth trail with a similar name.

An out-and-back to Alice Lake is different from the longer Alice–Toxaway Loop. The Forest Service identifies Alice, Toxaway, Twin, and Farley lakes along that broader loop. Do not accidentally commit to the whole circuit because a map app presents it as the default option. Choose your route, turnaround, and overnight plan before starting.

Getting to Pettit Lake and finding parking

Check the Sawtooth National Forest alerts and current trail reports before departure. A recreation listing is not a live assurance that access roads or crossings are suitable for your group.

The Forest Service places Pettit Lake Recreation Area west of Highway 75 on Forest Road 208. Use the official recreation-area page for access information and check current forest alerts before the drive. Build the trip around the actual trailhead rather than a pin dropped at the lake itself.

Parking is a real constraint. The Forest Service’s 2025 management notice describes registration and a one-in, one-out system when the trailhead reaches capacity. An early arrival is a useful strategy, not a reservation or guarantee. Have another outing in mind and never turn roadside vegetation into improvised overflow parking.

Stanley is a useful town base for a Sawtooth hiking trip. Allow time for breakfast, filling water containers, and the final trailhead approach. The trailhead information page says potable water is not available, so do not arrive expecting to fill every bottle there.

Understand the fee and wilderness permit

A free wilderness permit is required. The Forest Service says permits are available at the trailhead; parties of eight or more must arrange a large-group permit in advance through the Sawtooth National Recreation Area. Read the current group restrictions before bringing a club, reunion, or other large party.

The free wilderness permit does not mean trailhead parking is free. In its May 2025 notice, the Forest Service announced a $10 single-day use pass at Pettit Lake Trailhead, payable by cash or check, plus an annual option. Check the official fee announcement and current on-site instructions for changes or overnight payment details. Do not assume a particular pass is accepted without confirmation.

Creek crossings and seasonal conditions

The Forest Service specifically warns of deep, swift water crossings in early summer. A warm day in Stanley does not establish safe conditions higher on the route. Ask for current trail information, inspect each crossing, and be willing to turn around. Reaching the lake is not worth entering water that exceeds your group’s ability.

Choose footwear and spare clothing for wet conditions, and protect essential insulation inside your pack. Never use another hiker’s willingness to cross as proof that your own party can do so safely. Children, dogs, and heavily loaded backpackers may face different problems at the same crossing.

The trailhead page lists a May–September operating period, but that is not a promise of snow-free hiking throughout those months. Check snow, creek levels, weather, wildfire closures, and smoke close to departure. Carry offline navigation, rain protection, extra food, and a headlamp even if you intend to finish well before dark.

Dogs, camping, and protecting the basin

The Tin Cup trailhead page instructs visitors to keep pets leashed. Motorized vehicles and bicycles are not allowed in designated wilderness. Keep your group together around other hikers and stock, and do not let a dog chase wildlife or disturb people resting near the lake.

Campfires are not permitted on the Alice–Toxaway Loop. The Forest Service encourages portable cook stoves instead. An existing ring of stones does not override that restriction. Check current fire orders as well, since broader restrictions can affect stove use or other activities.

For an overnight trip, review the Sawtooth Wilderness regulations before choosing a campsite. Plan food storage, waste disposal, and water treatment rather than sorting them out after reaching the basin. Use durable surfaces, avoid expanding existing camps, and pack out everything you carry in.

Choose an alternative before the trailhead fills

Compare Fishhook Creek Trail for a different Sawtooth outing, or research Sawtooth Lake if you want another major lake destination. Neither should be treated as an automatic substitute without checking its own conditions and demands.

Our Sawtooth hiking guide, national recreation area guide, and statewide hiking hub can help spread a trip across several days. For Alice Lake, the best plan is the one that leaves room to turn back, wait for better conditions, or enjoy a different trail.

Questions before you go

Is the Alice Lake wilderness permit the same as the parking pass?

No. The wilderness permit is free, while the Forest Service announced a separate Pettit Lake Trailhead day-use fee in 2025.

Is this the full Alice–Toxaway Loop?

No. This guide describes an out-and-back to Alice Lake. The full loop is a separate, longer itinerary requiring its own planning.

Sources & planning resources

Select a pin for a guide. Map: © OpenStreetMap contributors. Locations are planning aids, not navigation or access permission.